A Jakob Nielson Moment
First bullet point: “users comment on the content first; if the content is not relevant, then they don’t care about any other aspect of the design”
Link this to the discussion of the “page paradigm” and the recent mention of a survey (user testing?) done with location of search input fields vs. links to search and the discussion gets even more interesting.
Suffice it to say, I am not dead set against the search box being front and foremost. I wanted to push against the edges of the desire to see what gave and what didn’t. Afterall, if you look at my history here I have more often than not put a search field forward (e.g., gateways and admissions but now switched back to link).